If the Montreal Canadiens want to rebuild, general manager Marc Bergevin shouldn’t be the guy to lead it.
The Montreal Canadiens have been a mess for the better part of the past two and a half seasons. It’s time the club accepts General Manager Marc Bergevin has put together a flawed team and must move on to a rebuild without him. He has had plenty of time to build a steady foundation the Canadiens can grow on but has failed to do so.
For the past three seasons, many could look at Montreal and see obvious holes on the roster. In the 2015-16 season, the Canadiens got off to an incredible start to their season courtesy of Carey Price. The goaltender won his first seven starts of the season while only allowing a combined nine goals against. Unfortunately, Price got hurt not long after and only managed five more games the rest of the year.
More from Puck Prose
- Detroit Red Wings 2023 Rookie Camp Has Plenty of Ups and Downs
- This Columbus Blue Jackets rookie doesn’t want to be forgotten
- 2 trades the Boston Bruins must make to secure the Stanley Cup
- 3 reasons the Avalanche won’t win the Stanley Cup in 2024
- This is a big year for Alex Turcotte and the Los Angeles Kings
Without their franchise goaltender, Montreal’s season became a disaster. The team had gone 10-2 in October but in December and January had a combined record of 6-18-1. The great start to the season was lost as the Canadiens would miss the playoffs.
Losing the best goaltender in the world is a blow no team could fully recover from. However, witnessing the loss of Price crumble the Canadiens after their hot start truly showed how the team was completely dependent around one player.
As a result of the disappointing 2015-16 season, Bergevin would make the trade that’ll continue to be discussed in Montreal for decades. Moving P.K. Subban for Shea Weber is a deal many in the Canadiens fan base are still trying to recover from. Subban is perhaps the most beloved former Canadien without a Stanley Cup ring. His entertaining personality and fantastic work in the community turned him into a loveable figure in Montreal.
Related Story: Canadiens All-Time Dream Team
Trading Subban was tough to swallow for the fan base, especially after the awful 2015-16 season, but trading him for a player four years older was also hard to comprehend. Weber was a proven leader and helped anchor the Nashville Predators defense for years. He’d also won two gold medals with Canada at the Olympics so it wasn’t like Montreal was receiving a bad player by any stretch. However, rarely do deals work out for both sides when one team trades a player in his mid-20s entering his prime for a player in his 30s exiting his.
Montreal tried to claim Subban’s new contract which carried a cap hit of $9-million per season was set to kick in and the team couldn’t afford it. Instead, they chose to acquire Weber’s cap hit of $7.857 million for an underwhelming annual savings of $1.143 million. Weber’s contract also lasts four more seasons compared to Subban’s, taking him until the 2025-26 season where Weber will be 40-years old.
Bergevin not only traded for a player four years older than the one he was trading, but he also took on four additional years of term with a minimal difference in annual salary. If this wasn’t a losing scenario from the moment the deal was confirmed it soon will be. Factor-in Erik Karlsson and Drew Doughty are likely to sign contracts in the near future worth $12 million per season and Subban at $9 million becomes even more reasonable.
Another reason behind moving Subban were rumors he wasn’t great in the locker room and teammates didn’t like him. What did Bergevin do once Subban was out of town? He signed Alex Radulov for the 2016-17 season, a guy who was kicked off the Predators during the playoffs once upon a time and had been playing in Russia for years because he wasn’t considered a team guy and had a poor attitude.
Only the Radulov signing was a home run and it may go down as the greatest thing Bergevin did while with the Canadiens. At least up until he didn’t re-sign Radulov after his 54-point season, allowing him to sign with Dallas where he’s played exceptionally well.
More from Montreal Canadiens
- Penguins: Grading how each team did in the Erik Karlsson trade
- Montreal Canadiens and Detroit Red Wings make a decent trade
- Montreal Canadiens: Is New Acquisition DeSmith the Answer in Goal?
- The winners and losers from day one of the 2023 NHL Draft
- 2023 NHL Draft Live Updates: News, Draft Selections, Trades and More
It made no sense to not re-sign Radulov, the Canadiens couldn’t score during the 2016-17 season. They somehow managed to make the playoffs but once they got there were quickly eliminated because they simply had no offense. Not re-signing Radulov when he fit in great and the team was desperate for offensive weapons continues to haunt the team today.
Part of the reasoning behind not re-signing Radulov was acquiring Jonathan Drouin to replace him. The move would have made sense if Drouin simply cost cap space to acquire and not the 19-year old defenseman the Tampa Bay Lightning received in return for trading Drouin. In the immediate results of trading Drouin for Mikhail Sergachev, the defenseman currently has more goals, assists, and has a plus/minus differential of plus-29.
Sergachev and Radulov would make the Canadiens an entirely different team. Instead, Bergevin acquired a young player who was unproven at centre and placed the weight of the team’s offense on his shoulders. He unintentionally placed such a weight on Drouin by not acquiring any other forwards to assist him. He used cap space that could have gone to Radulov on defensive-defenseman Karl Alzner. One of the last players capable of chipping in offensively and one Montreal simply didn’t need.
Bergevin has mismanaged cap space in the short-term and long-term. He’s starting to mismanage the farm system along with key future assets. He has one of the best goaltenders in the world but fails to surround him with any goal scoring. Even last season during the trade deadline, Bergevin failed to acquire any offensive support instead choosing to chase fourth liners and at-best sixth defensemen.
He even traded away offense last season by moving Sven Andrighetto to the Colorado Avalanche in exchange for Andreas Martinsen. Martinsen played nine games in Montreal before being traded to the Chicago Blackhawks. Andrighetto has produced 33 points in 55 games since joining the Avalanche.
Next: Each NHL Team's New Year's Resolution
The Canadiens are presently a mess and need to rebuild but they also must do so without Bergevin leading the charge. Allowing Bergevin to tear down and trade away key players would be a mistake.
With rumors Max Pacioretty is being shopped, Bergevin shouldn’t be the person making the trade. The right man behind the job could potentially fetch a return similar to what the Avalanche received for Matt Duchene. If the Canadiens want to rebuild properly, the right man for the job is not Bergevin.