NHL season preview: 5 bold predictions for the 2019-20 season

The 2019-20 NHL season is finally upon us. Here are five bold predictions for how things will play out.

The 2018-19 campaign was one of the most unpredictable and thrilling in the history of the NHL. Obviously, nobody saw the St. Louis Blues winning the Stanley Cup after a miserable first half, but here they are getting ready to defend their title.

On top of that, it was hard to give the New York Islanders much of a chance after losing their franchise player in 2018 free agency. But mastermind head coach Barry Trotz guided them to the number two seed in the Metropolitan Division, which led to him winning the Jack Adams Trophy.

More from Puck Prose

• Detroit Red Wings 2023 Rookie Camp Has Plenty of Ups and Downs
• This Columbus Blue Jackets rookie doesn’t want to be forgotten
• 2 trades the Boston Bruins must make to secure the Stanley Cup
• 3 reasons the Avalanche won’t win the Stanley Cup in 2024
• This is a big year for Alex Turcotte and the Los Angeles Kings

Other surprises included the Carolina Hurricanes, who went from “Bunch of Jerks” to the Eastern Conference Final. And the Tampa Bay Lightning, who recorded 62 wins and 128 points, couldn’t even salvage a playoff win against the eighth-seeded Columbus Blue Jackets.

Well, we’re in for plenty of more surprises ahead of 2019-20. There are some playoff teams from last year that figure to regress quite a bit, while a handful of non-postseason teams look ready to finally break through this year.

So which teams will disappoint us? Which coaches will fail to make it through the entire year? Who will win the prestigious awards, and most importantly, who’s taking home the Stanley Cup? Here are five bold predictions for the 2019-20 NHL season.

5. Pittsburgh Penguins Playoff Streak Ends

The Pittsburgh Penguins currently have the longest NHL playoff streak, having made it every year since Evgeni Malkin‘s rookie 2006-07 season. That’s 13 consecutive years of making the playoffs, highlighted by Stanley Cup championships in 2009, 2016, and 2017.

But for the first time in the Sidney Crosby era, it strongly appears that Pittsburgh’s playoff window is closing rapidly. Sure, Sid The Kid is still a top-two player in the NHL, even at the age of 32. But Malkin (33) isn’t getting any younger, and you have to be worried about his recent injury history.

And sure, general manager Jim Rutherford had no choice but to deal away sniper Phil Kessel, but replacing a reliable 20-30 goal-scorer and 80-point player is easier said than done. Alex Galchenyuk, whom the Penguins acquired from the Arizona Coyotes in the Kessel trade, is going to have a tough time producing the same stats as “Phil the Thrill.”

But the vastly improved Metropolitan Division and the Eastern Conference as a whole will make it even harder for Pittsburgh to maintain its playoff streak. The Philadelphia Flyers will be better after hiring Alain Vigneault as head coach.

The New York Rangers landed the prized 2019 free agent in Artemi Panarin. Trade acquisition Jacob Trouba and rookie Kaapo Kakko will also make huge differences on Broadway. And finally, the New Jersey Devils drafted Jack Hughes first overall before landing All-Star blueliner P.K. Subban.

An aging core, the loss of Kessel, plus a rapidly improving division will lead to the end of Pittsburgh’s playoff streak.

3. Both 2019 Stanley Cup Finalists Miss The Playoffs

The last time both Stanley Cup finalists missed the playoffs in the following year? You’d have go back to 2007, when the Carolina Hurricanes and Edmonton Oilers failed to qualify following their epic seven-game series, won by the Canes.

Well, the defending champion St. Louis Blues and Boston Bruins both face strong uphill climbs as they try to get back to the Finals. The good news is that both teams are bringing back all their core players from 2018-19, but the Stanley Cup hangover is pretty difficult to ignore. It seems to hit Stanley Cup finalists far more often than not.

What are the odds that the Blues will be able to regain that incredible second half momentum after standing as the NHL’s worst team on Jan. 3? It doesn’t help that the Central Division is loaded with legitimate Stanley Cup contenders in the Colorado Avalanche, Dallas Stars, Nashville Predators and Winnipeg Jets.

As for the Bruins, their Atlantic foes made necessary upgrades and figure to push hard for top-three spots in the division. This includes the Florida Panthers as well as the Montreal Canadiens.

Plus, what are the chances that 34-year-old Patrice Bergeron and 31-year-old Brad Marchand both repeat career years? Charlie Coyle is going to regress after a strong showing in the postseason. Goaltenders Tuukka Rask and Jaroslav Halak will also take steps back after impossible-to-repeat 2019-20 season performances.

The Cup hangover, more difficult divisions as well as the lack of lady luck this time around will add up to both the Blues and Bruins missing the postseason in 2020.

2. Avalanche Clean Up At Award Ceremony…Big Time

The Colorado Avalanche fell just one game shy of reaching the Western Conference Final last year. But the team can only get better from here, thanks to a rapidly improving core, the addition of two-way center Nazem Kadri, plus a full season of Cale Makar.

Nathan MacKinnon is coming off the best season of his career, where he tallied 41 goals and 99 points. Colorado upset the Calgary Flames in the opening round of the postseason and they’re primed to take it a step further in 2019-20.

The prediction here is that the Avalanche will be cleaning up at the NHL Awards ceremony next June, the same way the Tampa Bay Lightning did this past season. For starters, Colorado will come away with the Presidents’ Trophy after posting 115 points.

MacKinnon will win both the Hart Trophy and the Art Ross after tallying 45 goals and 107 points. Head coach Jared Bednar will win the Jack Adams after leading Colorado to their first Presidents’ Trophy since the 2000-01 season.

We won’t stop there just yet. Though Makar will just miss out on a Calder Trophy nomination, starting goalie Philipp Grubauer will be a finalist for the Vezina Trophy. He’ll build off a career year in which Grubauer went 18-9-5 with three shutouts and a .917 save percentage. I’ll predict that he narrowly loses it to Andrei Vasilevskiy.

But the Avalanche will nonetheless mop up the competition at the Awards ceremony. It’ll be thanks in large part to the efforts of Bednar, MacKinnon, Grubauer and Makar.

1. Toronto Maple Leafs Win The Stanley Cup

Toronto Maple Leafs fans are sick of hearing about 1967 – the last year this team won the Stanley Cup. No, they haven’t won it all in the post-Original Six era. No, the drought isn’t going to drag on forever.

You can easily argue that the Maple Leafs are merely the third best team in the Atlantic Division. But I’m having a tough time trusting Tampa Bay after another disappointing performance in the playoffs. And as noted earlier, it’s hard to trust Boston given the age of their core players along with the looming battle against the Cup hangover.

I’m also not seeing how any ream in the Metropolitan Division can be better than the Maple Leafs. They have one of the league’s elite “big threes” in John Tavares, Auston Matthews, and Mitch Marner.

Of course, the Maple Leafs also boast tremendous depth at forward. Kasperi Kapanen and Andreas Johnsson each scored 20 goals last year, while Zach Hyman chipped in with 21. William Nylander, a two-time 61-point man, will surely bounce back after a lengthy contract led to a disappointing year.

He’s been inconsistent in the playoffs, but goalie Frederik Andersen should perform nicely with Tyson Barrie joining a solid defensive unit that consists of Morgan Rielly (72 points last year) and veteran shutdown man Jake Muzzin.

With an elite offensive machine, a quality blue line and a top 10 goalie, the Maple Leafs will finally break through and end over a half-century of heartbreak. They’ll have learned from all those painful playoff losses.

Toronto will meet MacKinnon and the Avalanche in the Stanley Cup Final. Tavares will win the Conn Smythe as he leads the Maple Leafs to a thrilling six-game series victory.