San Jose Sharks: 3 players they should trade by the deadline

This season is all but over for the San Jose Sharks. But they can recoup some assets with a few trades. Here’s who they should be shopping.

Over the past few years, the San Jose Sharks have made a bunch of moves to go all-in and try to win a Stanley Cup. General Manager Doug Wilson has bet a lot on this team winning a title. Unfortunately, it has become painfully clear that it didn’t work out.

The Sharks came into the 2019-20 season with high hopes, but have yet to be anything close to as good as people anticipated them to be. Entering Jan. 10, they have a 20-22-4 record and their .478% point percentage is the seventh-lowest mark in the NHL. The Sharks are eight points out of a wild card spot and nine points out of third place in the Pacific Division.

It’s time for the Sharks to admit their plan to win a Stanley Cup failed. They’ve invested a lot of assets into this team (including their 2020 first-round pick), but they can still recoup a few of them by trading some players at the deadline.

More from Puck Prose

• Detroit Red Wings 2023 Rookie Camp Has Plenty of Ups and Downs
• This Columbus Blue Jackets rookie doesn’t want to be forgotten
• 2 trades the Boston Bruins must make to secure the Stanley Cup
• 3 reasons the Avalanche won’t win the Stanley Cup in 2024
• This is a big year for Alex Turcotte and the Los Angeles Kings

The Sharks likely aren’t going to make any earth-shattering moves because, simply, nobody’s going to want any of their huge contracts. However, if they play their cards right, they can recoup some of what they’ve given up and begin what could be a very painful rebuilding process.

It would be ideal for the Sharks to trade Joe Thornton because he’s somebody who teams would love to add. Also, let’s not kid ourselves, Jumbo Joe deserves a Stanley Cup, gosh darn it. Thornton riding out into the sunset with a Stanley Cup would easily be up there with Raymond Bourque retiring on top.

Alas, Thornton has expressed zero intentions to leave San Jose. He didn’t want to leave even after the Sharks stripped him of his captaincy and reportedly wanted him to leave. So why would Thornton leave now?

Here’s a look at the three players the Sharks should trade (other than Thornton, which obviously isn’t happening).

3. Melker Karlsson

I had you for a second, didn’t I? No, the Sharks shouldn’t trade Erik Karlsson. Even if they wanted to, who’s touching that contract? Nobody. Melker Karlsson, however, is a different story. He’s in the last year of his deal before he becomes an unrestricted free agent. The 29-year-old forward has a $2 million cap hit.

Karlsson would add something to a contender’s bottom-six forward group. In 42 games this season, he has three goals and four assists for seven points. However, scoring isn’t his specialty. Karlsson’s specialty is his penalty killing.

He averages nearly two minutes per game shorthanded and leads the NHL’s best penalty killing group. Karlsson would be a great addition to any contender who’s looking to bolster their special teams.

Karlsson’s also fairly cheap with just a $2 million cap hit. He has a history of being a reliable bottom-six forward. Last season, for example, Karlsson had 16 points. He’s usually hovered right around that.

Teams Who Could Be Interested

I could see the Edmonton Oilers being interested, though the Sharks might have to retain some salary to make it work. They certainly need forwards to help jump-start their bottom six and Karlsson will be one of the more affordable options.

2. Brenden Dillon

I got you again, didn’t I? You thought I was going to say Erik Karlsson or Brent Burns, didn’t you? Well, the San Jose Sharks should trade a defenseman. It’s just not one of them. Ideally, it would be Marc-Edouard Vlasic, whose decline has been brutal, to say the least. However, nobody’s going to want him. That won’t be the case for Sharks defenseman Brenden Dillon.

Much like Melker Karlsson, Dillon has one year left on his deal before he becomes a free agent in July. He has a $3.27 million cap hit and is averaging just over 19 minutes of ice time per game this season. In 46 games, Dillon has one goal and 10 assists for 11 points. He’s 29 years old and is left-handed.

Dillon’s underlying stats are quite promising. He has the second-highest CorsiFor percentage at 5v5 among all Sharks defensemen, trailing only Erik Karlsson. Dillon is also quite capable on the penalty kill. The Sharks would probably like to keep him around, but they might not have the cap space to do so. Ergo, trading Dillon seems like a logical move for the San Jose Sharks.

Teams Who Should Be Interested

The New York Islanders seem like a team that would make sense for Dillon. They recently lost Adam Pelech due to injury. Dillon would be a solid replacement. He has played a similar role to the one Pelech plays for the Islanders.